November 15, 2007
Taking judges to court
Within less than a
week, Houston solo Randall
Kallinen filed two separate
suits against judges on
behalf of clients. On Nov.
13, Kallinen filed Burns
v. Mayes, et al. in
federal court in
Houston, alleging
that
410th District Judge K.
Michael Mayes’
policy of jailing
probationers who provide
“dilute” urine samples --
meaning the urine has a low
creatinine level -- violated
Paul A. Burns’ rights to due
process and equal protection
under the law. “He was in
jail 44 days for an
accusation of dilute urine,”
Kallinen says of Burns. The
suit also names Montgomery
County and John Does as
defendants. Mayes refers
reporters to Ray Johnson,
assistant county attorney
for
Montgomery County.
Johnson, who represents the
county but does not
represent Mayes, declines
comment.On Nov. 7, Kallinen
filed suit against
Texas Court of Criminal
Appeals Presiding Judge
Sharon Keller
on behalf of the widow of
executed murderer Michael
Richard. Marsha Richard
alleges in Richard v.
Keller, et al. that
Keller ordered the CCA
clerk’s office not to accept
paperwork concerning Michael
Richard after 5 p.m. on
Sept. 25, the day that the
state executed him. Keller
declines comment on that
suit, which Kallinen
originally filed in a
Houston federal court and
subsequently moved to
federal court in Austin. A
decade ago, Kallinen sued
the 22 criminal district
judges in Harris County over
an administrative order that
prohibited the district
clerk and sheriff from
releasing addresses and
phone numbers of
unrepresented defendants in
pending cases. Kallinen,
who represented criminal
defense attorney Lee Scham,
won that case. In 1997,
U.S. District Judge Kenneth
Hoyt of
Houston granted
Scham’s motion for summary
judgment in Scham v.
District Courts Trying
Criminal Cases, et al.,
holding that the judges did
not have authority to issue
the order. But Kallinen
says suits against judges
are difficult. “What you’re
doing is saying, hey,
judicial branch, limit your
own powers, which is not an
easy thing to do,” Kallinen
says.
-- Mary Alice Robbins
-- Mary Alice Robbins




